This summer, 2025, the culinary channel Food Network put together a list of the best pizza slices in each state and we were honored to be selected as New Jersey’s representative for Best Slice!

Here’s what Food Network said about us:

“While New York City gets all the pizza cred, New Jersey’s pizzaiolos can stand up to the best of the Big Apple contenders. And set yourself apart in the Garden State, you’ve gotta know your dough. Peter and Sal Lombardo, owners of Dominick’s, certainly do. They learned the trade in the Carroll Gardens neighborhood of Brooklyn — basically the pizza mecca of the United States — before opening up shop in Jersey. Their pizzeria is now known as the oldest one in Sussex County. The duo sell a fantastic Brooklyn pizza that’s a bit on the spicy side, as well as the rare New York-style Palermo square pie with marinara, red onions, herbs and spices.”

Thank you, Food Network, for choosing Dominick’s Newton and to all our customers – the regulars and first-timers – we look forward to seeing and serving you, always!